Architectural vs. 3-Tab Shingles for Idaho Winters: Lifespan, Warranty, and Fit

by | Sep 10, 2025 | Asphalt shingles

Architectural vs. 3-Tab Shingles for Idaho Winters: Lifespan, Warranty, and Fit

Choosing between architectural and 3-tab shingles comes down to performance in wind and snow, expected lifespan, and budget.
For most homes in Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg, architectural shingles are the go-to for longer service life and better storm performance, while 3-tab can still fit tight budgets or outbuildings.

At a glance

  • Durability: Architectural (laminated) shingles are thicker and typically last longer than 3-tab.
  • Wind & weather: Architectural styles generally have higher wind resistance and stronger sealants—helpful during spring wind events and winter freeze-thaw.
  • Appearance: Dimensional look (architectural) vs. flat, uniform look (3-tab).
  • Cost: Architectural costs more upfront but often delivers lower lifetime cost due to longer service life.
  • Use cases: Architectural for most homes; 3-tab for sheds, garages, or when budget and timeline are primary.

Quick comparison

FeatureArchitectural (Laminated)3-Tab
ConstructionTwo or more layers laminated for thicknessSingle layer with cutouts (tabs)
Expected lifespanLonger, due to thicker mat and stronger sealantsShorter, more prone to wear in harsh climates
Wind performanceGenerally higher wind resistance when installed per specLower wind resistance; tabs can lift or crease
Cold-weather fitBetter for snow load and freeze-thaw cyclesAcceptable for milder exposure or outbuildings
AppearanceDimensional, varied shadow linesFlat, uniform pattern
Upfront costHigherLower

When 3-tab still makes sense

  • Outbuildings: sheds, detached garages, or utility structures.
  • Tight budgets or short timelines: when lower upfront cost is the priority.
  • Matching existing: small patch repairs on older 3-tab roofs.

Installation details that matter in Eastern Idaho

  • Underlayment & eave protection: synthetic underlayment plus ice & water shield at eaves/valleys helps with wind-driven rain and ice dams.
  • Starter, drip edge, and flashing: continuous drip edge and correctly lapped flashing improve performance in gusty storms.
  • Ventilation: balanced soffit intake and ridge/roof exhaust reduces ice dams and extends shingle life.
  • Nailing pattern: follow manufacturer and local best practices to meet regional wind conditions.

Choosing the right shingle for your home

If you plan to stay in your home and want stronger storm performance, go architectural.
If you need a quick, budget-minded solution for a lower-risk structure, 3-tab can work.
We’ll review roof pitch, exposure, ventilation, and any storm history in Idaho Falls, Rigby, or Rexburg to recommend the best fit.

Roof Replacement Service
Our Shingle Options
Get a Free Estimate

FAQs

Are architectural shingles heavier than 3-tab?

Yes. Architectural shingles use laminated layers, which adds weight and contributes to durability and a dimensional look.

Do architectural shingles really last longer?

They typically do, thanks to thicker construction and stronger sealants. Actual life depends on installation quality, ventilation, and exposure.

Will 3-tab hurt my resale value?

Buyers often prefer the look and performance of architectural shingles on primary homes. On outbuildings, 3-tab is common and expected.

Can I mix architectural and 3-tab on the same property?

Yes. Many homeowners choose architectural for the house and 3-tab for sheds or detached garages to balance budget and performance.



Impact-Resistant (Class 3 & 4) Shingles in Eastern Idaho: Are They Worth It?

by | Sep 5, 2025 | Asphalt shingles, Roof Inspection

Impact-Resistant (Class 3 & 4) Shingles in Eastern Idaho: Are They Worth It?

Impact-resistant (IR) shingles are engineered to handle hail and wind-blown debris better than standard shingles.
In Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg—where spring winds and occasional hail roll through—Class 3 or Class 4 shingles can reduce storm damage risk and may qualify for insurer credits. Always confirm details with your carrier.

At a glance

  • What “Class 3/4” means: Independent impact testing (UL 2218). Class 4 is the highest common rating.
  • Why upgrade here: Straight-line winds and periodic hail can crease or fracture standard shingles.
  • What to expect: Higher upfront cost, stronger mats/binders, and potential insurance considerations.
  • Still needed: Proper installation, ventilation, and eave protection (ice & water shield).

What impact-resistant shingles are

IR shingles are typically architectural (laminated) shingles designed with modified asphalt and reinforcement to absorb impact without fracturing the shingle mat.
Ratings come from UL 2218 tests that drop steel balls to simulate hail. Class 4 withstands the toughest test level commonly used in residential roofing.

Quick comparison

FeatureStandard ArchitecturalIR Class 3IR Class 4
Impact resistanceGoodBetterBest (highest common rating)
Wind performance*Strong when installed per specStrongStrongest (often higher published ratings)
Upfront cost$$$$$$
Potential insurance credit**UncommonPossibleMore common (carrier-dependent)
Best fitCalmer exposures, tight budgetsSome hail/wind exposureHail-prone areas, highest protection

*Wind performance depends on manufacturer specs, fastening pattern, and ventilation.
**Discounts vary by carrier, policy, and documentation—always confirm with your insurer before purchase.

When IR shingles make sense in Idaho Falls, Rigby & Rexburg

  • Recorded hail nearby: Neighbors or recent seasons with hail reports.
  • Tree cover & debris: Branches or pinecones frequently strike the roof.
  • Open exposure: Properties that see strong, sustained winds.
  • Long-term ownership: You plan to stay and want fewer storm-related repairs.

Insurance notes (what to ask your carrier)

  1. Do you offer a premium credit for UL 2218 Class 4 roofs? Any forms or photos required?
  2. Will the credit apply to all slopes or only if the entire roof is upgraded?
  3. Does the policy include any cosmetic damage exclusions for metal accessories paired with IR shingles?
  4. What documentation should my roofer provide (material labels, invoice, photos)?

Installation details still matter

  • Underlayment & eave protection: Synthetic underlayment plus ice & water shield at eaves/valleys.
  • Starter & drip edge: Proper starter strips and continuous drip edge for wind and water control.
  • Nailing pattern: Follow manufacturer and local best practices to meet regional wind conditions.
  • Ventilation: Balanced intake/exhaust to help control ice dams and extend shingle life.

Free estimate and product options

We install impact-resistant shingles across Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and nearby communities.
We’ll compare Class 3 vs Class 4 products, confirm installation details, and provide documentation for your insurer if needed.

Roof Replacement Service
Impact-Resistant Options
Request a Free Estimate

FAQs

Do impact-resistant shingles look different?

No noticeable difference from the ground on most brands. They’re typically architectural shingles with enhanced mats and binders.

Will Class 4 shingles lower my insurance premium?

Some carriers offer credits for UL 2218 Class 4 roofs, but programs vary by insurer and policy. Ask your carrier before purchase.

Do I still need ice & water shield with IR shingles?

Yes. IR shingles resist impact; ice & water shield protects against ice dams and wind-driven water at vulnerable areas.

Are IR shingles worth it if hail is rare?

If you have open exposure to strong winds, overhanging trees, or you plan to own the home long-term, IR shingles can still be a smart upgrade.



Hail vs. Wind Damage on Asphalt Shingles: Eastern Idaho Quick Guide

by | Aug 28, 2025 | Severe Weather

Hail vs. Wind Damage on Asphalt Shingles: Eastern Idaho Quick Guide

Not sure if a recent storm left hail or wind damage on your roof?
Use this quick visual guide for Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg homeowners.
From the ground with binoculars, you can spot key signs and decide when to call a pro.

At a glance

  • Hail: random circular divots, crushed granules, soft or bruised shingle mats.
  • Wind: lifted or creased shingle tabs, missing shingles, bent or displaced flashing.
  • Check safely: walk the perimeter, stay off the roof, document with photos, and look for granules at downspouts.
  • Next step: if multiple slopes show issues, schedule a professional inspection and documentation for insurance.

Quick comparison: what to look for

Hail damage signsWind damage signs
Random round impact marks with crushed or missing granulesTabs lifted or folded back, creases along the shingle lines
Soft spots or bruising when pressed, matte-looking areasMissing shingles, exposed nails, disturbed ridge caps
Granule piles at gutter outlets after stormsShingles flapping during wind, torn sealant strips
Indentations on metal flashings or soft metalsBent drip edge, displaced flashing near chimneys or walls

Safe at-home inspection steps

  1. Walk the perimeter. Use binoculars from the ground. Do not climb onto the roof.
  2. Photograph each slope. Take wide shots and close-ups of anything suspicious.
  3. Check gutters and downspouts. Look for fresh granule piles and dented metal.
  4. Look in the attic. Check for daylight at sheathing joints and damp insulation.
  5. Document the storm. Note the date, time, and wind or hail reports in your area if available.
  6. Call a professional. If you see creases, missing tabs, or widespread impacts, schedule an inspection.

When to call Idaho Roofing

In Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and nearby towns, straight-line winds and fast-moving thunderstorms can damage multiple slopes in a few minutes.
If more than one face of the roof shows impacts or creasing, get a documented inspection before making an insurance claim.

Roof Repair Service
Insurance Claims Help
Request an Inspection

What to do first after a storm

  • Take photos of the roof, gutters, siding, and yard. Include close-ups of shingles and any debris.
  • Save receipts for temporary protection, such as tarps or emergency repairs.
  • Do not pressure-wash the roof. Do not scrape impacts or chip ice.
  • Contact a licensed roofing contractor to create a written inspection report with photos.

Proudly serving Eastern Idaho

We inspect and repair asphalt shingle roofs across Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and surrounding communities.
Our team provides clear documentation that you can share with your insurer, plus repair or replacement options that fit local weather conditions.

FAQs

Can hail damage be hard to see?

Yes. Hail can bruise the shingle mat without obvious granule loss at first. If you suspect damage, have a professional check multiple slopes and soft metals for impact marks.

What if I only see granules in the gutters?

Some granule loss is normal over time, but fresh piles after a storm indicate impacts or accelerated wear. Ask for an inspection to confirm the source.

Should I call insurance or a roofer first?

Start with a roofer. A documented inspection helps you understand the scope and whether a claim is appropriate. If you file a claim, share the report and photos with your adjuster.

Is a small repair OK after wind damage?

Yes, if the roof is otherwise healthy. Isolated lifted or missing tabs can often be repaired. Widespread creasing or aging across several slopes usually points to replacement.




Idaho Falls Roof Replacement Cost in 2025

by | Aug 22, 2025 | New Roof In Idaho

Idaho Falls Roof Replacement Cost in 2025: Real Ranges, Factors, and Timelines

In 2025, most Idaho homeowners invest about $6,000 to $20,000+ to replace an asphalt shingle roof, depending on size, pitch, tear-off, materials, ventilation, and disposal.
In Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg, cold winters and spring winds often justify ice and water shield at eaves and balanced attic ventilation for long-term durability.

At a glance

  • Typical 2025 range (asphalt shingle): $6,100–$20,700+ for a single-family home.
  • Biggest drivers: roof size and pitch, tear-off vs overlay, underlayment upgrades, ventilation, flashing details, permits, and disposal.
  • Why local specs matter: Idaho Falls design criteria list about 47 psf ground snow load, ~115 mph ultimate wind, and ~30 inch frost depth, which influence materials and fastening patterns.

Sample cost ranges by roof size

These examples use common installed price ranges for architectural asphalt shingles to help you self-scope before requesting an estimate.

Approx. area (sq ft)Installed price per sq ftIllustrative 2025 range
1,500$4.00–$8.50$6,000–$12,750
2,000$4.00–$8.50$8,000–$17,000
3,000$4.00–$8.50$12,000–$25,500

Ranges are illustrative and assume architectural asphalt shingles with standard accessories. Final pricing depends on site conditions and product choices.

What drives cost in Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg

  • Tear-off vs overlay: Full tear-off increases labor and disposal but protects long-term performance and warranty eligibility.
  • Underlayment & eave protection: Ice and water shield at eaves and valleys is common for our snow climate.
  • Ventilation upgrades: Balanced intake and exhaust help manage ice dams and extend shingle life.
  • Roof complexity: Steep slopes, multiple planes, chimneys, skylights, and dormers add labor and flashing detail.
  • Permits & disposal: City or county requirements and haul-off fees vary by jurisdiction.
  • Wind fastening: Following local wind design values and manufacturer nail patterns improves storm performance.

How long a roof replacement takes

Most single-family asphalt shingle replacements finish in 1 to 3 working days once materials are on site, weather permitting. Larger, steep, or complex roofs can take longer.

DayWhat happens
0Material delivery, safety setup, and permit checks
1Tear-off and dry-in with synthetic underlayment
2Shingle installation and flashing details
3Final punch list, magnetic cleanup, and walkthrough

Repair or replace after a storm

If damage is isolated to a small area or a few lifted or missing tabs, a focused repair can be the smart move. Widespread creasing, granule loss, or aging across multiple slopes generally points to replacement.

Ways to save without cutting corners

  • Choose architectural asphalt shingles with a solid manufacturer warranty.
  • Bundle small carpentry or gutter work with your reroof while access is easy.
  • Ask about seasonal scheduling and financing options.
  • Keep attic ventilation and insulation in balance to protect the new roof.

Serving Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and nearby towns

We install and replace asphalt shingle roofs across Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and surrounding communities. Every job includes a clear scope, daily site cleanup, and a final walkthrough.

Roof Replacement Service
Request a Free Estimate

FAQs

Will my insurance cover storm damage?

Policies vary, but sudden wind or hail damage can be covered while wear and tear is not. Document the roof and yard, then schedule a professional inspection to review options.

Do local codes require ice and water shield?

Requirements depend on the jurisdiction and roof design. Many Eastern Idaho homes benefit from an ice and water barrier at eaves and valleys because of snow and freeze-thaw cycles. Your estimator will confirm code requirements for your address.

Can I roof over existing shingles?

Overlays are sometimes allowed, but a tear-off lets us correct hidden issues, install full eave protection, and keep warranties straightforward. Most long-term solutions start with tear-off.

How do I compare bids fairly?

Line up scope and specs: underlayment type, ice and water coverage, ventilation, flashing method, cleanup, warranty terms, and permit and disposal fees. Ask for proof of insurance.



Fall Roof Maintenance Checklist for Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg

by | Aug 12, 2025 | Roof Inspection

Fall Roof Maintenance Checklist for Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg

A quick fall tune-up protects your roof before winter. Use this checklist to clear gutters, inspect flashing and penetrations, seal exposed fasteners, and confirm attic ventilation.
Do these steps before the first sustained freeze so snow and ice do not trap moisture.

At a glance

  • Gutters and downspouts: clear debris and confirm smooth drainage.
  • Flashing and penetrations: check step flashing, chimney areas, pipe boots, and sealants.
  • Shingle surface: look for lifted tabs, exposed fasteners, and missing granules.
  • Attic ventilation: verify open intake and exhaust, and look for daylight leaks or damp insulation.
  • Tree limbs: trim branches that hang over the roof line.

Quick checklist you can print

TaskGoalDone
Clean gutters and flush downspoutsPrevent overflow, ice buildup, and fascia damage□
Inspect step and chimney flashingSeal gaps that allow wind-driven rain and meltwater□
Reseal pipe boots and exposed fastenersStop small leaks before winter□
Ground-level shingle scan with binocularsSpot lifted tabs, missing shingles, or creases□
Attic check for daylight and damp insulationCatch early leak or ventilation issues□
Trim branches near eaves and ridgeReduce abrasion and storm breakage□

If anything looks questionable, schedule a professional inspection before snow season.

How to complete each step safely

  1. Prepare and protect. Use sturdy ladders on level ground, gloves, and eye protection. Keep someone nearby while you work.
  2. Clear gutters. Remove leaves and grit, then run water to confirm downspouts flow freely. Check for leaks at seams and miters.
  3. Inspect flashing. From the ground or ladder, check step flashing at sidewalls, chimney counter-flashing, and headwalls. Look for gaps or rust. Reseal minor joints with compatible roofing sealant.
  4. Seal penetrations. Examine pipe boots and any exposed fasteners. Replace cracked boots and reseal exposed nail heads with a roofing-grade sealant.
  5. Shingle surface scan. With binoculars, look for missing shingles, lifted tabs, or creases near the shingle lines. Note any areas that need repair.
  6. Attic ventilation and moisture. Verify that soffit vents are open and not blocked by insulation. Check for damp insulation, stains, or daylight at sheathing joints.
  7. Trim vegetation. Cut back branches that can rub shingles or dump heavy snow loads onto the roof.

When to call Idaho Roofing

In Idaho Falls, Rigby, Rexburg, and nearby towns, fall winds and early freezes can turn small issues into winter leaks.
If you see creased tabs, widespread granule loss, soft spots, or flashing gaps, book a professional inspection.
We can also install heat cables in problem eaves and confirm proper ice and water shield at vulnerable areas.

Roof Maintenance Service
Gutter Cleaning and Repairs
Schedule a Fall Inspection

FAQs

When should I clean gutters in Eastern Idaho?

Clean in fall after most leaves drop, then check again after the first freeze-thaw cycle. If you have heavy tree cover, plan on a mid-season sweep.

Do heat cables solve ice dams?

Heat cables can reduce ice at problem eaves, but they do not fix the root cause. Air sealing, balanced ventilation, and insulation address the source of ice dams.

Is moss a concern in our climate?

Moss is less common here than in coastal climates, yet north-facing slopes and shaded areas can grow algae or lichens. Avoid pressure washing. Use roof-safe cleaners and protect landscaping.

Can I do this without getting on the roof?

Yes. Most checks can be done from the ground with binoculars and from the attic. Leave roof-level work to trained crews.




Ice Dams in Eastern Idaho: Causes, Prevention, and Safe Removal

by | Aug 5, 2025 | Severe Weather

Ice Dams in Eastern Idaho: Causes, Prevention, and Safe Removal

Ice dams form when heat from the home melts roof snow that refreezes at cold eaves. The resulting ridge traps water, which can back up under shingles and leak inside.
In Idaho Falls, Rigby, and Rexburg, the solution is part prevention (air sealing, insulation, ventilation) and part protection (ice and water shield at eaves/valleys).Hail Damage on an asphalt shingle roof in Idaho Falls Idaho

At a glance

  • Root cause: warm roof deck from air leaks or low insulation, plus cold eaves.
  • Result: meltwater refreezes at eaves and crowns into a ridge that traps water.
  • Prevention: air seal the attic, add/level insulation, and ensure balanced intake/exhaust ventilation.
  • Protection: install ice and water shield at eaves, valleys, and other vulnerable areas during reroofing.
  • Removal: use ground-level roof rakes and professional steaming. Avoid chisels and salt that can damage shingles and landscaping.

Why ice dams happen here

Our winters bring periods of sustained cold and on-roof snowpack. Heat escaping into the attic warms the roof deck above living spaces while eaves remain cold.
That temperature difference causes meltwater to refreeze at the edges and overhangs.

Prevention checklist (best long-term fix)

  • Air sealing: seal attic bypasses around can lights, bath fans, plumbing stacks, and top-plate gaps.
  • Insulation: add or level attic insulation to consistent depth; protect soffit intake with baffles.
  • Ventilation: balance intake (soffits) and exhaust (ridge or roof vents) to keep the roof deck cold.
  • Eave protection: specify ice and water shield at eaves/valleys during reroof projects.
  • Gutters & drainage: keep gutters clear to reduce refreeze at the edge.
  • Heat cable (supplemental): use on problem eaves as a band-aid, not a substitute for air sealing/insulation.

Safe removal options (short-term relief)

These steps reduce immediate risk. Work from the ground or hire a pro—do not chip or pry ice off shingles.

MethodWhat it doesNotes
Roof rake (from ground)Removes snow above the dam to reduce meltwaterUse a roof-safe rake with rollers; pull snow down, not up
Professional steam removalCuts channels through the ice without damaging shinglesBest for active leaks or heavy dams
Calcium chloride socksOpens small melt channels through the damPlace carefully; avoid rock salt and contact with plants

Avoid: chisels, axes, hammers, pressure washers, or rock salt—these can damage roofing and shingles.

When to call Idaho Roofing

If you see ceiling stains, attic frost, or ice ridges at eaves, schedule an inspection. We’ll document conditions, safely relieve dams if needed, and recommend permanent fixes like air sealing, ventilation adjustments, and underlayment upgrades during reroofing.

Roof Repair Service
Seasonal Maintenance
Request an Ice Dam Inspection

FAQs

Do heat cables fix ice dams permanently?

No. Heat cables can reduce ice formation at problem eaves, but they do not address the root cause. Air sealing, insulation, and balanced ventilation are the long-term solution.

Will insurance cover ice dam leaks?

Policies vary. Some cover sudden damage from ice dams while excluding long-term maintenance issues. A documented inspection helps clarify options.

Is gutter cleaning really that important?

Yes. Clogged gutters slow meltwater at the edge and increase refreeze, which makes dams worse. Clean them before sustained freezes.

Can I prevent dams without accessing the attic?

You can reduce risk by raking roof snow after storms and keeping gutters clear, but lasting results usually require attic air sealing and insulation improvements.




Top Three Benefits of a Metal Roof in Eastern Idaho

Top Three Benefits of a Metal Roof in Eastern Idaho

by | Jan 12, 2025 | New Roof In Idaho

Why Metal Roofing Is the Best Choice for Homes in Eastern Idaho

If you’re a homeowner in Eastern Idaho facing long winters, heavy snow, and unpredictable windstorms, metal roofing may be the smartest upgrade you can make. At Idaho Roofing, we specialize in installing metal roofs built to withstand the unique challenges of this region—while also improving energy efficiency and increasing your home’s curb appeal.

(more…)

Affordable Roof Repair in Idaho Falls: What You Need to Know

Affordable Roof Repair in Idaho Falls: What You Need to Know

by | Jan 4, 2025 | Roof Inspection, Roofing Insurance Claim

Ignoring a small roof issue today can turn into a costly nightmare tomorrow. Timely roof repair protects your home and saves you money in the long run. However, many homeowners avoid repairs due to the misconception that roof fixing is always expensive. The truth is, with the right contractor, you can find affordable, high-quality roof repair services that won’t break the bank.

In this guide, we’ll explore the common roof issues that homeowners face, provide tips for finding affordable roof repair in Idaho FallsNavigating Roofing Costs in Idaho: Affordability and Beyond, and show you why Idaho Roofing is the trusted choice for local repairs. Whether it’s a small leak or storm damage, we’re here to help you make informed.

(more…)